he was in the employment of Mr Watkins this year say he saw Mr Carley and Mr Watkins meet in yesterday Tuesday the 9 Inst in a field they both were farming in belonging to the estate of Arthur West decd in a field formally called the Lucious place say he heard Mr Carley ask Mr Watkins what right he had to drive his cattle in the field he Mr Watkins answered and said because he had rented the land they were advancing towards each other all the while they were talking Mr Carly was advancing fastest until they come within about four corn rows of each other says Mr Corley ordered Mr Watkins to stop Mr Corley shot Mr Watkins as soon as he ordered him to stop with a double Barrel shot Gun one time